Evaluating the value of veterinary medicine

Back in veterinary school, I was faced with the decision about what exactly I wanted to do after graduation. It seemed there were two paths I could choose from: one would lead towards becoming a general practitioner and one would lead towards becoming a specialist.

Unlike some of my peers who knew exactly what they wanted from the minute they entered the clinics, the decision wasn’t simple for me. Each option had proverbial pros and cons and benefits and drawbacks. I wasn’t entirely sure how to proceed.

Career indecision wasn’t really a new concept for me. Although I’ve wanted to be a veterinarian for as long as I can remember, the “kind” of vet I wanted to be evolved as I aged.

As a very young child, I wanted to be a vet who treated only puppies and kittens. I’m not sure exactly when I discovered this idealistic notion of what a vet did was not even close to being true, but once it did, I know my goals started to change a bit.

As a “horsey” kid growing up on Long Island, I spent my pre-teen years dreaming of being a racetrack veterinarian. After realizing the thoroughbred racing industry wasn’t nearly as akin to the glamorous world of the Black Stallion novels as I once thought, once again I found my romantic notions of veterinary medicine shifting.

I spent time contemplating a career as a zoo vet or a conservationist, but as is true for so many things in life, things eventually came full circle, and by the time I was accepted to veterinary school, I decided I would be a general practitioner and spend my days treating companion animals.

This was, of course, before I knew what specialty veterinary medicine entailed. Once I started vet school, I was exposed to a caliber of medicine not unlike what is available for my own health. Specialty medicine appealed to my intellectual side and my creative side. After a few years I knew it was the path I wanted to take.

I struggled with what would be the ideal specialty for me to pursue. Truthfully, oncology was the farthest from my mind. One of my biggest concerns was the astronomical amount of finances directed towards saving the life of only one dog or cat was compared to what could be spent towards helping so many animals in a shelter or rescue organization.

It’s not unusual for owners to spend $5,000 or even $10,000 when treating a pet with cancer. Some owners will spend $20,000 or more on pets treated with surgery, radiation therapy, and chemotherapy. Or course I recognize this is not even close to an option for the vast majority of people, but for a small group of pet owners, there is literally no price to be put on their pet’s healthcare.

I’ve been thinking a lot about the disparity in the different “fields” of veterinary medicine. Some racehorses are worth millions of dollars as unproven yearlings and there are immense expenses related to their veterinary care. I routinely recommend treatments costing several thousands of dollars for a single animal, knowing I’m not likely to cure them of their cancer, but I’m typically able to extend their lifespan by months to years. Even “routine” veterinary care for dogs and cats can run into hundreds of dollars per visit to the vet. Yet there are so many pets in shelters who may never be afforded the chance for advanced treatment should it arise, or worse yet, are put to sleep for lack of space, or for a treatable, but expensive, medical condition.

As veterinarians, I think we each struggle with the reality we simply cannot save every animal and I still battle with the financial aspects of my chosen career more often than I would like. Maybe it’s more pronounced in a field such as oncology, but it’s not at all exclusive to my chosen specialty.

Is it wrong for an owner to spend the same amount of money on one pet that could be used to help so many more? Everyone will have his or her own convictions when answering this question. Until you are in the position of having to make that actual choice, I think it’s best not to respond at all as your answer could be very surprising under different circumstances.

Just as my career goals changed over time, so may an opinion on the “value” of a pet, especially if it were your own animal you were making that decision about.

Enjoy this article? You may also be interested to learn about What Makes a Veterinary Specialist So Special?

One thought on “Evaluating the value of veterinary medicine

  1. suzannemcannon says:

    Thank you for this thoughtful, sensitive article. There is no black or white answer here. I agree with you – what an owner is willing to spend depends on any number of factors, any of which may change over time or due to circumstance. It is a very personal decision.

    It is wonderful that veterinary medicine can now offer diagnostic and therapeutic options that are as sophisticated as those available to humans. The challenge, though, is the affordability of these options. It is hard to say no to a treatment that may save or extend your pet’s life, but it is heartwrenching to come to terms with the reality that you may not have the financial means to procure that treatment.

    There are no easy answers, and there is no perfect solution. Thank you, though, for tackling a tough topic that is relevant to pet owners and vets alike.


What do you have to say about this?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s